The owner of a landmark hotel in Mid Argyll has accused Argyll and Bute Council of obstructing his plans to renovate the waterfront building, forcing it to remain closed.
The Cairnbaan Hotel has been closed since December 2023 and conflict between the council and the new owner over the style of replacement windows has stalled renovations on the main building. However, a modern, glass-fronted restaurant adjoining the hotel is due to open this year.
“I have been trying to move forward with the hotel renovations for more than a year now, but throughout this time the council has shown no interest in communicating with me,” owner Mark Watson told the Advertiser.
“Most recently, on January 8, I had an email from an agent at the council apologising for the delay but since then I have heard nothing. I have even contacted senior managers and reached out to the head of the department, but none of them has had the manners to respond.”
Mr Watson explained that the hotel’s existing single-glazed wooden windows are in a poor state of repair and he would like to replace them with the same sash design but in a more resilient material and with double glazing.
“It’s a 200-year-old building, which desperately needs modernising,” he said. “The chap from the council that came out to see it said the windows didn’t need to be replaced which is ridiculous. I have sent pictures to the council via my architect to show how bad they are and even after that they are now insisting that I cannot put two panes of glass in. What I don’t understand is why they won’t consider the carbon footprint of their position – and who is going to pay the heating bill?”
Mr Watson has been asked by the council to explain his reasons for each window replacement.
He said: “We had to justify the need to change every one of the windows but even then the council said we hadn’t given enough detail. I find it astonishing that they are doing everything to make this so difficult. The obstacles they put in the way make running a business in Argyll and Bute simply unsustainable, impacting jobs and the economy. I have found things so much easier in other places.”
When the Advertiser contacted Argyll and Bute Council about Mr Watson’s complaints a spokesperson said: “We have engaged with Mr Watson, and he is aware that we require further information before the council can reach a decision on whether or not to grant consent. We hope to receive that soon in order to progress the application to a conclusion.

“We want to see the hotel open and have been flexible in our approach to enable significant works to proceed. This includes permitting extensive demolition works and a replacement modern extension to refurbish the hotel and revised access arrangements. Cairnbaan Hotel is a category B listed building which is identified by Historic Environment Scotland in their designation to be of regional importance and protected by law.”
The modern extension referred to by the spokesperson will accommodate a glass-fronted restaurant which is expected to open at the end of this year.
“I’m toying with leaving the hotel and opening the restaurant, which we’re all really excited about,” said Mr Watson.
“It will have a beautiful, really smart dining area and a bar with a beer garden out the back.
“It would be such a shame not to improve the hotel. We have had such amazing support from the local community, and I know everyone wants to see the hotel brought back to its former glory.”
Why not try these links to see what our West Coast AI can tell you.
(Please note this is an experimental service)
Yes! I would like to be sent emails from West Coast Today
I understand that my personal information will not be shared with any third parties, and will only be used to provide me with useful targeted articles as indicated.
I'm also aware that I can un-subscribe at any point either from each email notification or on My Account screen.